
The 2012 season has the potential to be one of the best with 6 World Champions on the grid, half of whom have won at least twice. Everyone’s hoping for a really competitive season with a close finish (like 2007 where the top 3 drivers were separated by a single point). Or a nail-biting finish such as 2008 where Felipe Massa was World Champion for 35 seconds until Timo Glock made sure that Hamilton didn’t throw it all away again.
Recently we conducted a poll on our website to find out who you thought was the best driver in F1. The top three results were: 37% Alonso, 17% Hamilton and 14% Vettel. We have a look at your top 3 analysing their abilities, while also taking a look at the other drivers who could be considered the best currently on The Grid.
Hamilton is certainly a very talented racing driver, but is unreliable and lacks a clinical finish. This is what sets him apart from Schumacher, Alonso and Vettel, and it’s not a coincidence that these drivers are multiple Championship winners.
Formula 1 truly is a team sport, and because of that we can never definitively say who is the best or most talented driver. Even when drivers are at the same team, they are often driving with slightly different packages than their teammates. However, it can be defined as when a driver can consistently outperform whatever car he is given that we see a real talent.
The merry-go-round of drivers at the back of the grid is in the vague search for a truly great driver to emerge. Anyone remember Scott Speed? Yuji Ide? Anthony Davidson? Unfortunately yes to the last – why is he allowed to commentate?! However these drivers raced in similarly awful cars to Alonso, Vettel and Schumacher, but why were these drivers able to stand out?
Fernando Alonso outperformed the dreadful Minardi in 2001 and was picked up by Renault after a single season in the sport, with whom he went on to win 2 World Championships during the period of Ferrari dominance no less. Even when he has had a good car he has still outperformed it – his second spell at Renault, and the 2011 season at Ferrari. No one thought that car was much good and Massa showed us the capabilities of what it should achieve, but Fernando consistently finished on the podium with that car.
Sebastian Vettel. What can you say about the young German sensation? Like Alonso he impressed at the back of the grid – scoring points in his first ever GP with BMW Sauber, and winning a race with Toro Rosso. No one gives him enough credit for that – this was a Toro Rosso, the reject car of the (at the time) joke Red Bull team, which Vettel put on pole and then won the race! In an absolutely flawless 2011 season, he cemented just how good he is onto the potential shown in his Championship winning 2010 season, as well as the 2009 season, which Brawn absolutely walked through, yet he still finished as the 2nd placed driver.
Michael Schumacher has won the World Championship 7 times. That should be the end of the argument over who is the best driver, but Schumacher has not performed as well when his car isn’t great. Yes he won 5 in a row, but the only real challenge then was from Barrichello who was contractually instructed to move over and let him win. Secondly, what happened between ’96 and ’99, Michael? I mean Damon Hill won a title. Jacques Villeneuve won. These are average drivers who won titles. Average drivers don’t win World Championships in a time of great drivers. Otherwise, we would now be hailing 5-time Champion Nick Heidfeld. Thirdly, in his return to F1 he has struggled to outperform his teammate, let alone the car and this is just not great driver form.
Should the other World Champions on the grid be in this list? Hamilton and Button are very good drivers but need at least another title to be considered with the other three. And anyone who saw Kimi racing in WRC will know why he doesn’t make the list.
Had Webber finished a close second behind Vettel this year then we could have said that the success was car related, rather than down to the driver. However 134 points behind speaks for itself. Alonso was my driver of the season, the Ferrari should never have been able to keep up with the Red Bulls and Mclarens. If you have learnt nothing from last season Ferrari, don’t name a Formula 1 car after a pick-up truck (that’s an F150 joke which is slightly obscure, but well done if you got that).
At this stage it is too early to say for definite who is the best, but I believe that the 2012 Champion will be either Seb or Fernando, and it is likely that this season will settle the argument. Well, for another year at least.